By Royal Calkins
A Fresnoland reporter and teams of journalists from The Fresno Bee and Mariposa Gazette won top honors for public service in the 38th annual George F. Gruner Journalism Awards at Fresno State.
The Gruner Awards recognize outstanding journalism by newspapers and digital news operations around the San Joaquin Valley.
The awards highlight the best of local news media while demonstrating to students and the Valley the importance and value of journalism to the local community and a flourishing democracy. Ahead of the event, Fresno State journalism students had the opportunity to open doors for their future careers by connecting with 14 local media professionals in a “speed-networking” session.
“The energy in the room was incredible as students made connections with professionals and set up future meetings for possible jobs,” said Jim Boren, director of the Institute for Media and Public Trust at Fresno State.
Boren said a generous gift from George’s son, Richard Gruner, was announced at the ceremony. The endowment will fund the Gruner Awards every year in perpetuity.
Public service prize
In the larger newspaper/digital-only publications division, the public service prize was shared by Fresnoland and The Fresno Bee.
Fresnoland’s Gregory Weaver conducted an in-depth examination of the state Williamson Act’s broken promise to protect Fresno County farmland by providing property tax breaks for parcels threatened by development. Weaver found numerous examples of major property owners receiving greatly reduced tax bills, although their land is too remote to be subdivided for commercial or residential subdivision.
One of the judges, retired New York Times national intelligence reporter James Risen, said, “The tax bonanza for rich agribusiness inadvertently wrought by the Williamson Act was revelatory and maddening.”
The Fresno Bee shared the public service prize for its in-depth coverage of what judge Jim Newton called “the year’s most important and timely issue,” the regional implications of the national immigration crackdown. Newton, a UCLA instructor and former Los Angeles Times assistant editor, said the team of Erik Galicia, Melissa Montalvo, Maria G. Ortiz-Briones and Marina Pena dug deeply and deftly illustrated the issue in their series. Montalvo received the same prize last year.
The prize for public service by smaller dailies and weeklies went to the Mariposa Gazette for the second year in a row. This year’s top entry from Greg Little, Nicole Little and Tom Lyden started with a phone tip and ended with the resignation of the Mariposa County district attorney.
Out of the blue, the tipster claimed he had repeatedly sold methamphetamine to the DA and later provided text evidence to back up his story. Judge Risen called it a “reporter’s dream phone call” and Newton said the journalists followed it up with “solid, aggressive (and) readable” reporting.
Also for public service, honorable mention went to Serena Bettis of the Mid Valley Times, which covers parts of Fresno and Tulare counties, and Karis Caddell of the Sun Gazette in Tulare County. Bettis wrote about controversy over missteps by the Selma City Council and other issues involving investigations and hiring procedures. Caddell exposed delays and cost overruns involving the public utility district in Earlimart.
Best writing
The winning entry for best writing among the larger outlets and digital category went to Donald Munro of the Munro Review for his review of the play “Mojada.” The tightly written piece, judges said, packed a lot into its well-planned paragraphs in the Fresno-based arts publication. Munro teaches journalism at Fresno State and is the faculty adviser to The Collegian, the student newspaper at Fresno State.
Honorable mention for best writing in the same category went to Julianna Morano of Fresnoland for her deeply reported piece on the artists behind the murals beneath Fresno’s 180 Freeway. A judge noted that she brought both the art and the neighborhood to life.
In the smaller papers group, the winning entry came from Karis Caddell of the Sun Gazette. A judge wrote that she “took what could have been a straightforward new business story and turned it into a charming portrait of Monica Torres, who worked her way up from dishwasher to executive chef at the Visalia brunch spot Sunny Hyde Up.”
Honorable mention went to Ben Hensley of Fresno’s Business Journal for “Startup Grind,” about two entrepreneurs building a coffee business from the “grounds” up.
Best commentary
In the commentary category, first place in the large paper/digital only division went to recently retired Juan Esparza Loera of The Fresno Bee for his early warning about the nationwide immigration crackdown. Honorable mention went to Heather Parish of the Munro Review for her engaging and funny review of the play “Rent.”
For smaller papers, the prize for best commentary was won by Michael Braa of the Los Banos Enterprise. He drew on his heritage as a descendant of Native Americans and Europeans for a piece on immigration. A judge commented that it wove “powerfully through the nuances of personally belonging to two distinct streams of human history.”
Honorable mention went to the Mariposa Gazette’s Greg and Nicole Little for an editorial about excessive secrecy by county officials, brought to light by a case involving the newspaper.
Best news story
Winning the prize for best news story in the larger paper/digital group was Doug Hoagland of the Munro Review for his deep analysis of the flawed awards process for a Fresno art tax measure. Hoagland, who was a longtime features and investigative reporter for The Bee, has consistently led reportage on the troubled measure.
Honorable mention in the same category went to Lois Henry of SJV Water and Tim Sheehan of Intersection/The Central Valley Journalism Collaborative.
Henry broke the story about President Trump’s illogical and wasteful order to release water from Central California reservoirs in a useless effort to help combat the Southern California wildfires.
Sheehan was honored for a piece exploring the impacts of the reopening of a financially troubled hospital in Madera.
In the smaller papers category for best news story, top honors went to Jon Acevedo of the Mid Valley Times for another immigration-related story. He wrote about how the nationwide ICE roundups were impacting a local flea market by scaring away vendors and customers. A judge wrote that Acevedo “put a human face on a serious policy problem.”
Receiving honorable mention was frequent Gruner prize winner Parker Bowman of the Hanford Sentinel for his “heartfelt, empathetic and timely” portrait of the final days of an encampment of unhoused people.
Best feature writing
For feature writing, the winner in the large dailies/digital only division was Rachel Livinal of the Merced Focus, for an upbeat piece about how a 20-foot-tall pile of dirt inspired T-shirts, social media posts and even a mention on Good Morning America.
“How do you turn a pile of dirt into a fun, compelling read?” asked one of the judges. “Talk to a lot of people, gather lots of details, then let the story gently unspool.” Livinal received the same award at last year’s Gruner competition.
Honorable mention in the same category went to Esther Quintanilla of the Central Valley Journalism Collaborative for a piece on high school students learning the art of mariachi. The story, judges wrote, combined a good historical perspective and interviews that “provide some zest and keep the story moving.”
For feature writing in the smaller papers group, first place was claimed by Ben Hensley of the Business Journal for his piece on the intricacies of opening a small business, in this case, a new coffee shop. One judge called it “a good example of clear, concise writing that offers valuable tips to budding entrepreneurs.”
Karissa Hernandez of the Los Banos Enterprise took honorable mention for her piece on a recovering addict who channels his pain into music. “Good quotes make this flow like a melody,” a judge wrote.
Best news photo
Frequent Gruner prize winner Craig Kohlruss of The Fresno Bee took the top award for best news photo in the larger publication group. His entry showcased new citizens being sworn in with Yosemite’s majestic Half Dome for a backdrop. A judge wrote, “Beautiful use of the environment to tell the story of what the ceremony was about. It’s often challenging to get a dynamic photo from a ceremony, but this image certainly did.”
Honorable mention went to Peter Segall of the Bakersfield Californian for a photo of the police clearing an encampment of unhoused people. A judge commented on its “starkness.”
The winning photo in the small papers group came from Nick Smirnoff of the Tehachapi News for a “superb stop-action moment” at an apple-bobbing competition.
Honorable mention went to Hensley of the Business Journal for a photo of Fresno Mayor Jerry Dyer noshing at the opening of a new bagel restaurant. One judge wrote: “Old rule for photographers: Never take photos of someone eating. Better rule: Break rules.”
Best sports photo
In the larger paper/digital race for best sports photo, The Fresno Bee’s Eric Zamora took first for his shot capturing a ball-carrying football player hurdling over an opponent. “No caption needed,” one judge wrote.
Honorable mentions went to Rodney Thornburg of the Bakersfield Californian for his capture of a diving, sideways stretch by a soccer goalie and Andy Alfaro of the Modesto Bee for his photo of a tense moment in a soccer game.
In the smaller papers category for best sports photo, first place went to Amanda White of the Mariposa Gazette for a joyous, mid-air flag football photo. Honorable mention went to Nick Smirnoff of the Tehachapi News for capturing a motorcycle stunt rider reaching heights up to the grandstand lights.
Best sports story
Competition for best sports story in the large newspaper/digital-only division resulted in a tie between Ryan T. Blystone of the Bakersfield Californian and David Taub of GV Wire.
Blystone deftly put readers in the bleachers for a baseball game between the Bakersfield Train Robbers and the Vallejo Seaweed of the Pecos League.
Taub developed a takeout on the pitiful 1985 San Francisco Giants — a team that lost 100 games. A judge called it “a fun read about how a bunch of great Giants collectively gave fans the worst season ever, and what the players are up to now.”
In the smaller paper group, the sportswriting winner was Jon Hammond of the Tehachapi News for his piece on a gathering of former football players to remember the “Miracle on the Mountain,” their title-championship game from 40 years earlier. A judge said that Hammond’s “well-written and researched” piece put her in the middle of the game.”
The award for best sports story went to Kason Clark of the Sun Gazette for her piece on a girls’ basketball team that came from behind to win their division title following the death of their head coach midseason.
The Gruner Awards honor the late George F. Gruner, who retired as executive editor in 1988 after 33 years at The Fresno Bee. The McClatchy Co., publisher of The Bee, established the awards in 1989. Entries are judged by professional journalists from outside the contest area.
The Department of Media, Communications and Journalism at Fresno State independently administers the awards, which are sponsored by the James B. McClatchy Foundation and the Fresno State Institute for Media and Public Trust.
